New Decree on Administrative Penalties in Vietnam Healthcare Sector

December 7, 2020

New Decree on Administrative Penalties in Vietnam Healthcare Sector

Informed Counsel

Vietnam’s efforts against the outbreak of COVID-19 in the country have been largely successful, and despite two distinct spikes of local transmission, in both cases the spread was halted relatively quickly. As these complications from the COVID-19 pandemic have been playing out in Vietnam throughout 2020, it became clear that effective and strong enforcement of healthcare regulations, especially those related to disease control, was crucial.

On September 28, 2020, the government of Vietnam took action on this by issuing Decree No. 117/2020/ND-CP (“Decree 117”), which provides penalties for administrative violations in the healthcare sector. Some provisions of Decree 117—mostly those related to disease control and epidemic situations—took effect immediately, with the remainder taking effect on November 15, 2020. The decree, which was based on a draft proposed by the Ministry of Health, replaced Decree No. 176/2013/ND-CP on the same matter.

The main administrative penalties under Decree 117 are reprimands and fines. Depending on the severity of the violation, violators may also be subject to additional penalties such as suspension of a certificate of eligibility for pharmaceutical business (CEPB), a license for healthcare operation, or other licenses and practicing certificates for up to 24 months; confiscation of illegal items; suspension of operations for up to 24 months; or deportation. Furthermore, remedial measures such as forced return of illegal earnings, compulsory quarantine and medical examination, public correction, or compulsory payment of treatment fees may also be applied.

Some key highlights of Decree 117 are discussed below.

In relation to disease control, the maximum fine for failure to comply with quarantine is doubled to VND 20 million (USD 855) for infected people of type-A contagious diseases, and VND 10 million (USD 427) for those who are not infected but are asked to quarantine. Failure to declare one’s contagious disease to a doctor could be subject to a fine up to VND 3 million (USD 130), which is 10 times higher than the penalty provided in the repealed decree. These penalties took effect on September 28, 2020.
Exploiting an epidemic situation by price gouging of medicine or medical supplies is subject to a fine of up to VND 30 million (USD 1,300) for individuals or VND 60 million (USD 2,600) for companies and organizations. Violators may also be forced to suspend operations (which includes CEPB suspension for pharmaceutical business entities) for up to 24 months, and any illegal earnings will have to be returned to the buyers or sellers.
The decree also provides a number of new penalties for the pharmaceutical sector. A fine of up to VND 10 million (USD 427) is imposed for various violations in pharmaceutical practice, such as being the chief pharmacist at two or more pharmaceutical business entities simultaneously, or practicing pharmacy not in accordance with the scope of practice stipulated in the relevant certificate. Engaging in the sale of pharmaceuticals without a CEPB or at an address different from the one stated in the CEPB is subject to a fine of up to VND 120 million (USD 5,155). The operations of the violator may also be suspended for up to nine months.

Borrowing or lending a CEPB is punishable by a fine of up to VND 60 million (USD 2,600) and suspension of the CEPB for up to 24 months.
Foreign-invested entity (FIE) importers that conduct activities directly related to drug distribution (except for drugs manufactured in Vietnam by the FIE importer) could be subject to a fine of up to VND 160 million (USD 6,900).
For a drug that has been granted a marketing authorization in Vietnam, failure to notify the relevant authority of the recall of that drug in any country other than the country issuing the certificate of pharmaceutical product could subject the violator to a fine of VND 140 million (USD 6,000). The same fine is also applicable to submission of drug registration documents that are not based on actual research or manufacturing data. Remedial measures include compulsory recall of the drug and recommending that the relevant authority revoke the marketing authorization.
Decree 117 also introduces some provisions on violations relating to the use and sale of liquor and beer. Employing minors in advertisements for liquor and beer is subject to a fine of up to VND 40 million (approximately 1,700). Selling or providing liquor and beer to minors is subject to a fine of up to VND 3 million (USD 130) for individuals or VND 6 million (USD 260) for companies and organizations.

Altogether, Decree 117 sharply escalates the penalties for some violations that have been proliferating amid the COVID-19 pandemic, while some other penalties remain unchanged or are slightly amended. Multinational pharmaceutical companies should note, in particular, the new penalties applicable to FIE importers, as drug distribution remains a sensitive area in Vietnam, and enforcement can be unpredictable.

Download Full Article

Related Professionals

Chuyen Hong Huu Le

Vietnam

+84 28 628 45687

Email

Kim Thi Anh Nguyen

Vietnam

+84 28 628 45678

Email

RELATED INSIGHTS

October 25, 2023

Personal Data Protection and Healthcare Services in Indonesia

One significant development in the health sector in Indonesia is the use of information technology and communication in the implementation of health efforts—particularly digital health services such as telehealth and telemedicine integrated into the country’s National Health Information System. This development was addressed in a major new piece of legislation for the healthcare sector in Indonesia. Enacted in August 2023, Law No. 17 of 2023 concerning Health (the “Health Law”) provides the updates needed to support the development of healthcare services in Indonesia. Under the Health Law, health information system (HIS) providers must: Carry out processing of data and health information in the territory of Indonesia, except for certain limited and specific processing activities that may be conducted outside Indonesia when permitted by the relevant authorities and in compliance with relevant regulations. Ensure the reliability of its HIS, including availability, security, maintenance, and integration with Indonesia’s National Health Information System. Provide quality health data and information. Process data and health information, which includes planning, collection, storage, inspection, transfer, utilization, and destruction. Record its data- and information-processing history. Protect every person’s data and health information. Obtain approval from the relevant personal data subject or comply with relevant regulations if the processing of data and health information involves an individual’s health data. Inform the data owner if there is a failure to protect data and individual health information. The Health Law’s personal data protection requirements listed above appear to be aligned with the provisions in Law No. 27 of 2022 concerning Personal Data Protection (the “PDP Law”). Under this law, data and information relating to health are identified as “specific personal data,” the processing of which carries a high potential risk of impacting the relevant personal data subject. In the implementation of digital health services, patients’ personal data or medical records

October 19, 2023

Food Nutrition Labeling in Cambodia: What Are the Rules?

Cambodia’s Law on Food Safety came into force on June 8, 2022. This law has been widely regarded as a major legal development of the food safety framework in Cambodia, providing new rules, clarifying existing rules, and setting a clear framework for its implementation and enforcement. In addressing some of the key features of this new law shortly after it was passed in 2022, we remarked that we eagerly await implementing regulations. Since then, various regulations have been adopted, such as two regulations (Sub-Decree No. 13 and Prakas No. 80) on food surveillance, recalls, and seizure. These implementing rules are essential in ensuring that enforcement officers can remove noncompliant and unsafe foods from the market. Another key aspect of the Law on Food Safety is that it requires Khmer-language labeling on prepackaged food products. There has been a notable increase in the inclusion of Khmer labeling on food products in the market since June 2022, but noncompliance is still considerable, especially for imported foods. Further interesting labeling rules set by the Law on Food Safety include a requirement to provide nutrition information. This requirement has not yet been widely adopted, with many in the industry highlighting that the details of this labeling requirement are not clear. Indeed, the relevant article of the Law on Food Safety itself only sets the requirement for food products to bear nutrition labeling and does not spell out what detailed information should be provided or in what manner. However, a prakas (ministerial regulation) adopted months prior to the Law on Food Safety does set out clear guidance on nutrition labeling. As long as this earlier regulation is not replaced or abrogated, and as far as it does not conflict with later laws or regulations, it can be relied upon for guidance. What are the

September 20, 2023

Thailand Prepares to Renew Drug Marketing Authorizations as First Expiration Nears

Thailand is preparing to open its first renewal period for drug marketing authorizations (MAs) since the passage of the Drug Act (No. 6) B.E. 2562 (2019). Before 2019, MAs for pharmaceuticals and vaccines in Thailand had lifelong validity. The 2019 Drug Act stipulated that all new MAs would be valid for seven years and could be renewed. The 2019 law also set out expiration dates for existing pharmaceutical products registered and approved prior to the implementation of the law (i.e., before October 13, 2019): Drug MAs issued before January 1, 1997, expire on October 13, 2024. Drug MAs approved between January 1, 1997, and December 31, 2007, expire on October 13, 2026. Drug MAs approved between January 1, 2008, and October 13, 2019, expire on October 13, 2028. Based on these dates, the first renewal period for drug MAs will commence in the fourth quarter of 2023. To facilitate the renewal process, the Thai Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has publicized draft regulations and notifications on the required application form and documents, the rules and conditions, and the process for renewing an MA. In May 2023, the Thai FDA issued Ministerial Regulation Re: Renewal of Drug MA Licenses B.E. 2566 (2023) to prescribe the essential requirements for filing a renewal application: To renew a drug MA, holders must submit their renewal application to the Thai FDA within the one-year period before the MA’s expiration date. Renewal applications can only be submitted online via the Thai FDA’s electronic system. The Thai FDA will grant approval for an MA renewal if the following conditions are satisfied: The documents in relation to efficacy and safety are up-to-date, accurate, and in accordance with academic principles. The specification and analytical method comply with the official pharmacopeias as prescribed in the Drug Act, as amended.

September 15, 2023

Thailand Updates Rules on Conditional Approval for Emergency Use of Medicinal Products

In May 2023, Thailand issued a regulation on conditional approval for emergency use of medicinal products, replacing a series of similar notifications that had been issued to aid mitigation efforts during the COVID-19 pandemic. During the pandemic, regulatory authorities worldwide—including the Thai Food and Drug Administration (FDA)—reshaped the approval pathway for emergency drugs intended for the treatment of COVID-19. The Thai FDA published five Notifications Re: Conditional Approval for the Emergency Use of Medicinal Products to outline the registration requirements and channels of distribution for drugs intended for the diagnosis, treatment, or prevention of COVID-19. As the threat from COVID-19 was receding, the Thai FDA saw fit to prepare for the potential emergence of other serious communicable diseases by enabling the supply of timely medications for disease diagnosis, treatment, and prevention. The Thai FDA therefore cancelled the five COVID-19-related emergency use notifications, which were published in 2020 and 2022, and replaced them with the Notification Re: Conditional Approval for Emergency Use of Medicinal Products published in May 2023. Under the May 2023 FDA notification on emergency use, conditional approval can be applied to drugs supported by empirical scientific evidence demonstrating their capacity to diagnose, treat, alleviate, cure, or prevent a serious communicable disease. The drugs eligible for approval under this new emergency pathway include novel drugs that are not yet approved in Thailand, as well as existing drugs approved in Thailand but recently discovered to have additional potential indications for the diagnosis, treatment, alleviation, cure, or prevention of a serious communicable disease. Distribution The 2023 FDA notification also clearly defines permissible distribution channels based on the dosage form of drug products: Vaccines can be distributed to governmental organizations that have a duty to prevent or treat diseases, such as the Thai Red Cross Society (TRCS), the Government Pharmaceutical Organization

You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

Industries

Practices

December 7, 2020